Skip to main content

Argparse with environment variables

Project description

Argparse with environment variables. This module is both a derived argparse class supporting environment variables and a framework or set of proposed enhancements for extending argparse.

The Example

The following is taken from the __main__ conditional at the end of this module:

parser = EnvArgParser\
        ( prog="Test Program"
        , formatter_class=EnvArgDefaultsHelpFormatter

        ( '--bar'
        , required=True
        , env_var="BAR"
        , type=int
        , nargs="+"
        , default=22
        , help="Help message for bar."

        ( 'baz'
        , type=int

args = parser.parse_args()

Example output:

$ BAR="1 2 3 '45  ' 6 7" ./ 123
Namespace(bar=[1, 2, 3, 45, 6, 7], baz=123)
$ ./ -h
usage: Test Program [-h] --bar BAR [BAR ...] baz

positional arguments:

optional arguments:
  -h, --help           show this help message and exit
  --bar BAR [BAR ...]  Help message for bar. (default: 22) (env_var: BAR)

How it Works

This module tries to be very simple: it may look longer because it is well-commented. There is no code duplication. In fact version 0.1 (tagged) was even simpler: actions were tracked via the namespace argument of parse_args(), maintaining the precedence:

cmd args > env var > preexisting namespace > defaults

Basically it stores within the namespace a unique instance for each action with an environment variable key, if that variable exists. After argparse finishes parsing it executes the action associated with each remaining unique instance. The idea is this: if the action was provided via the command-line, it’ll have been overwritten from the namespace.

You can still use that version if you want, but it doesn’t handle actions which fail to set the dest attribute on the namespace. To be fair, such actions are exceedingly unlikely. For a while I considered sandboxing an empty namespace for each action and copying only the dest attribute back to the main namespace, but that would be artificially limiting. Instead…

Version 0.2 (tagged) is built around tracking actions. Whether an action has been seen as a command-line argument, and how often it has been called. Believe it or not, there are edge cases in which an action can be seen but not called. See the comments for more information.

The EnvArgParser class maintains the set of seen actions while every action, environment variable key or not, is embedded within a tracking object. Originally a function-local variable within the parsing function, the set of seen actions is lifted into the instance namespace and reset before each new parsing pass. Luckily there is a 1:1 call correspondence between seeing an action and calling _get_values, which now updates the set of seen actions. Each tracking object increments a counter whenever called and otherwise behaves exactly like the contained action, forwarding (almost) all attribute access.

An environment variable record, EnvArgRecord, is attached to each valid environment variable action whether or not that environment variable actually exists - for help-formatting reasons. Such actions will only be executed if the environment variable is available and the action hasn’t already been seen or been called.

As for actually parsing the environment variable, that hasn’t changed much between 0.1 and 0.2. Reflecting that the parsing function can be overridden per action, the default env_var_parse is a static method; the first argument is always the parser. The default mimics the parsing of argparse (counting, converting and checking values) without code duplication by relying on internal ArgumentParser methods. It’s actually quite simple - just two method calls. The arguments are split using shlex but your custom parser can use yaml, json, or whatever else you prefer. Whatever the case, the parsing function must return a tuple: the resulting value(s) and a list of extra values. As extra values usually raise an exception you might consider leaving this empty.

And that’s basically it, aside the from the value-checking boilerplate. As of python 3.7 the newly introduced intermixed parsing methods perform two-pass parsing, forcing EnvArgParser to track the parsing “depth”. The set of seen actions is only cleared before this two-pass process and the environment variables only parsed afterwards - both at the uppermost depth.

There is a help formatter which adds environment variable keys to the argument help, and an example mix-in class with argparse.ArgumentDefaultsHelpFormatter to add both environment variable keys and argument defaults. Custom help formatters can be created simply by inheriting from the appropriate base classes.

What comes next is just icing on top of the cake. While it isn’t actually used by this module nor does it change the default behavior it’s a nice showcase for what’s possible and perhaps useful for user-defined derived classes.

The original ArgumentParser is relatively monolithic while EnvArgParser uses cooperative OOP between action and parser to allow per-action overrides of parser methods. Whereas the parser would normally call its own methods it now calls into the action. By default the action calls the matching method from the parser’s base class, so out-of-the-box there is no behavioral change. As a proof-of-concept this is only implemented for _get_values and get_value but if useful can be extended to all methods via a custom __getattribute__. In the meantime feel free to add additional methods or override the default behavior by deriving from EnvArgParser and EnvArgAction.

The Proposal

Let’s step a bit back. Why can’t you just use argument defaults:

import argparse
import os

parser = argparse.ArgumentParser(formatter_class=argparse.ArgumentDefaultsHelpFormatter)
parser.add_argument("--foo", default=os.environ.get("FOO","bar"), help="FOO!")

That creates an artificial dependency between the default and the environment. In other words, it’s not what the user expects. Notice how the default doesn’t stay constant:

$ ./ -h
usage: [-h] [--foo FOO]

optional arguments:
  -h, --help  show this help message and exit
  --foo FOO   FOO! (default: bar)
$ FOO=456 ./ -h
usage: [-h] [--foo FOO]

optional arguments:
  -h, --help  show this help message and exit
  --foo FOO   FOO! (default: 456)

Unfortunately argparse is too much of a black box to cleanly modify and therefore this module serves as a working roadmap for proposed improvements. The important points:

  • Be more transparent about parsing.

    Maintain parsing state, such as the set of seen actions, within the instance namespace rather than as inaccessible method variables. Track parsing depth during multistage parsing. Have the base Action class track how often it has been called. Mark core parsing methods as a part of the public API.

  • Make parsing more modular.

    Create re-usable entry-points (methods) for:

    • parsing individual optional arguments.

    • parsing individual positional arguments.

    • checking for conflicts based on argument values.

    • handling exceptions (as a decorator).

    Right now the code is too monolithic.

  • Don’t force each argument to use the same parsing chain.

    Allow actions to overload important parser methods such as _get_values, _get_value or _match_argument.

The more trivial points:

  • Switch to new-style ({}) string formatting.

    Old-style (%) string formatting cannot access object attributes. The _get_help_string method is expected to return a format string which would be unable to access attributes of EnvArgRecord.

The Module

The code is well-commented, so here is a brief list of the provided classes:

  • EnvArgRecord

  • EnvArgParser

  • EnvArgAction

  • EnvArgHelpFormatter

  • EnvArgDefaultsHelpFormatter

  • Container


  • Python 3.7+

  • module: decorator (@PyPI)


GPLv3+; see LICENSE.txt


Yclept Nemo <pscjtwjdjtAhnbjm/dpn>

Project details

Download files

Download the file for your platform. If you're not sure which to choose, learn more about installing packages.

Source Distribution

envargparse-1.0.0.tar.gz (9.8 kB view hashes)

Uploaded Source

Built Distribution

envargparse-1.0.0-py3-none-any.whl (21.9 kB view hashes)

Uploaded Python 3

Supported by

AWS AWS Cloud computing and Security Sponsor Datadog Datadog Monitoring Fastly Fastly CDN Google Google Download Analytics Microsoft Microsoft PSF Sponsor Pingdom Pingdom Monitoring Sentry Sentry Error logging StatusPage StatusPage Status page