chATLAS_Benchmark 0.0.8

A Python package for LLM and RAG testing in high-energy physics applications (Originally for ATLAS in the chATLAS project).

chATLAS Benchmark

A Python package for LLM and RAG benchmarking and testing built for the ATLAS experiment as part of the chATLAS project

📚 Overview

chATLAS_Benchmark provides a flexible framework for testing and benchmarking LLMs and RAG models with robust storage and retrieval of past runs for comparison using SQL.

🌟 Key Features

• Set of benchmarking tests for RAG comparison
  • Semantic Similarity Score
  • F-1 Testing
  • ROUGE 1, 2 and l testing
  • Document Match scores
  • Answer Correct Score
• SQL storage of results for robust database operations

🚀 Quick Start

📥 Installation

pip install chATLAS-Benchmark

For Lexical Metrics test (should be downloaded automatically):

import nltk
nltk.download('punkt_tab')

For new QA pair Generation:

export OPENAI_API_KEY="<Your OpenAI Api Key>"

💡 Basic Usage

# Import the benchmarking module
from chATLAS_Benchmark import BenchmarkTest, fetch_metrics_results

# Initialize the test set
test = BenchmarkTest("/path/to/test.json")

# --- Run the RAG on the questions ---
# Assuming RAG.run() returns an answer and list of docs for each question
gen_answers = []
gen_docs = []
for q in test.questions:
    answer, docs = RAG.run(q)
    gen_answers.append(answer)
    gen_docs.append(docs)

# Set generated answers and documents on the test instance
test.set_generated_data(gen_answers, gen_docs)

# Run the scoring with any metrics you want
scores = test.score_test_set("LexicalMetrics", "SemanticSimilarity", "DocumentMatch")

# Save the results to the db
test.store_results(scores, db_name="database.db", name="NameOfRAG")


# See at all previous scored results in the db
df = fetch_metrics_results()

---

Contents

1. Installation
2. Requirements
3. Extending chATLAS_Benchmark
   • Adding New Tests
4. Current Metrics Overview
5. Project Structure and Imports

---

Installation

To install the package:

pip install chATLAS_Benchmark

---

Requirements

Python Dependencies

Dependencies should be installed automatically when installing the package, but a full list of requirements is given in requirements.txt in module root for reference.

Document Format

For DocumentMatch scoring it expects documents to be in Documentformat:

from chATLAS_Benchmark import Document

But any document with:

name_of_document = document.metadata["name"]

Would work (so langchain document format also compatible as long as the documents have their name in metadata).

---

Extending chATLAS_Benchmark

Adding New Tests

Currently, new tests can be added functionally but could(/should) be updated to use class inheritance.

Each testing method is implemented as a separate script in the /tests directory. To add a new test:

1. Write new test metric scoring method - return pandas DF

import pandas as pd


def myNewTestMetric(data:dict):
  """
  :param data: (dict) -
  {
    "questions": List[str],       # Original questions
    "answers": List[str],         # Generated answers
    "documents": List[List[str]], # Retrieved documents
    "test_answers": List[str],    # Expected answers
    "test_documents": List[List[str]] # Documents that generated the expected answers
    }
  """
  return pd.DataFrame()

2. Add the test name and function to the BaseBenchmark.implemented_tests dict

from chATLAS_Benchmark import BenchmarkTest

myTest = BenchmarkTest("testSet.json")

myTest.implemented_tests["MyNewTest"] = myNewTestMetric

3. Run The Testing

gen_answers = []
gen_docs = []
for q in myTest.questions:
    answer, docs = RAG.run(q)
    gen_answers.append(answer)
    gen_docs.append(docs)

# Set generated answers and documents on the test instance
myTest.set_generated_data(gen_answers, gen_docs)

# Run the scoring with any metrics you want
scores = myTest.score_test_set("MyNewTest")

4. Storing New Test to DB

Now the package was not built in the most scalable way, so this cannot be done without explicitly editing the source code for the chATLAS_Benchmark.test_utils.database_utils.py script.

You can follow the setup for the other tables in this script to add your own to it.

---

chATLAS_Benchmark Metrics Overview

The chATLAS_Benchmark package provides several evaluation metrics to assess the performance of Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) systems. These metrics help analyze the quality of retrieved documents and generated answers against a ground truth. The defined metrics fall into three main categories:

1. DocumentMatch

• Purpose: Evaluates whether the RAG system successfully retrieves the correct document that was originally used to generate the test question.
• How it works: The metric checks if the correct document is present within the set of documents retrieved by the system.

2. LexicalMetrics

These metrics assess the generated answer's textual similarity to the reference answer using lexical comparison techniques.

• Exact Match:

  • Compares the RAG/LLM-generated answer to the ground truth after stemming words to account for variations.
  • Returns True if the answers are identical post-stemming, otherwise False.

• F1 Score:

  • Measures the overlap between the true and generated answers using precision and recall.
  • The F1 score is the harmonic mean of precision and recall, capturing both false positives and false negatives.

• ROUGE Scores: The package computes the following ROUGE scores to evaluate overlap between the generated and true answers:

  • ROUGE-1: Measures overlap of unigrams (single words).
  • ROUGE-2: Measures overlap of bigrams (two consecutive words).
  • ROUGE-L: Measures the longest common subsequence (LCS) between the true and generated answers.

3. SemanticSimilarity

• Purpose: Evaluates the semantic similarity between the generated and true answers using embedding-based methods.
• How it works:
  • Both the generated and ground-truth answers are converted into vector embeddings using a pre-trained model.
  • The cosine similarity is computed between these embeddings, providing a score between 0 (completely dissimilar) and 1 (identical), with higher values indicating closer semantic meaning.

4. AnswerCorrect

• Purpose: Evaluates whether the generated answer is correct for the question relative to the generated answer
• How it works:
  • Takes original question, true answer and generated answer and sends them to GPT-4o-mini
  • 4o-mini evaluates yes it answers the question or no it does not answer the question correctly
  • If yes gets assigned a score of 1 for that question if no gets assigned a score of 0 for that question

---

These metrics provide a comprehensive evaluation framework to analyze both lexical accuracy and semantic understanding of RAG-generated responses, ensuring robust performance assessment.

Project Structure and imports

Project Structure:

chATLAS_Benchmark/
│   _version.py
│   __init__.py
│
├───Generation
│   │   gen_qa_pairs.py
│   │   gen_simple_qa_pairs.py
│   │   __init__.py
├───tests
│   │   DocumentMatch.py
│   │   LexicalMetrics.py
│   │   README.md
│   │   semanticSimilarity.py
│   │   test_benchmark_metrics.py
│   │   __init__.py
├───test_utils
│   │   database_utils.py
│   │   __init__.py

Module Imports:

# Standard Imports
from chATLAS_Benchmark import (
    BenchmarkTest,
    Document,
    fetch_metrics_results
)

# Sub Imports
from chATLAS_Benchmark.Generation import (
    generate_qa,
    generate_qa_from_named_files
)

🔧 Development Status

Current development priorities:

• More modular design
• Integration of answer correctness test
• Additional testing

CHANGELOG

0.0.8

Made lexical metrics automatically download required punkt model if using lexical metrics test

0.0.7

Fixes to fetch_metric_results so that we can return data even when we don't have all tests run for a particular model.

0.0.6

Minor update to package requirements.

0.0.5

Adding a print to scoring to show average number of documents returned per question.

0.0.4

New AnswerCorrect test for using an LLM to test if answer is correct.

0.0.3

Added ability to create a benchmark test on a dict instead of just Json files.

Added custom keys to benchmark test to load data with different keys to expected.

Added ability to load a set number of questions in the benchmark instance

Added AnswerCorrect score - simple LLM evaluation of is generated answer correct or not

0.0.2

Fixing loading file encoding for json

Fixing docstring for what type of file BenchmarkTest accepts

0.0.1

Initial Release

---

📄 License

chATLAS_Benchmark is released under Apache v2.0 license.

---

Made with ❤️ by the ATLAS Collaboration

For questions and support, please contact