compare-mcp

Multi-model code review with ranked todos and subagent dispatch, inside Claude Code CLI.

Claude Code is great at code review — but it only talks to one model. Copilot CLI recently shipped multi-model debug, letting you bounce a problem off GPT, Claude, and Gemini in one shot. Claude Code can't do that natively. This MCP server adds it: bring your own API keys, fan out to any combination of models, and get back a diffed, ranked list of what they each found.

Fan out any bug or task to multiple LLMs simultaneously, diff their unique insights, optionally run a debate round where models critique each other, then dispatch parallel subagents to implement the combined best fixes — each with its own git commit.

Demo

https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/8990dabb-bc61-4625-8930-c914cffe75da

/compare models → /compare review config.py for security issues → /compare --debate → /compare status

Architecture

Install

pip install compare-mcp
claude mcp add -s user compare-mcp -- python -m compare_mcp

Then grab the /compare skill and example config:

git clone https://github.com/carolinacherry/compare-mcp.git --depth 1
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills ~/.compare
cp -r compare-mcp/.claude/skills/compare ~/.claude/skills/
cp compare-mcp/.compare/config.example.json ~/.compare/config.json

Quick start

1. Edit ~/.compare/config.json — enable at least 2 providers by setting "enabled": true and adding your API key (either as a $ENV_VAR reference or paste the key directly)

2. In Claude Code:

   /compare memory leak in the tile rendering loop
   /compare race condition in the connection pool --debate --providers claude,openai
   /compare status
   /compare models
   

Config reference

Config lives at ~/.compare/config.json. API keys use $ENV_VAR syntax — expanded at load time.

Provider types

Type	SDK	Use for
anthropic	anthropic-python	Claude models directly
openai_compat	openai-python with custom base_url	OpenAI, Kimi, Minimax, Gemini, Ollama API, any compatible endpoint
cli	subprocess stdin/stdout	Ollama CLI, Codex CLI, any binary

Compare settings

Key	Default	Description
max_tokens	2048	Max tokens per provider response
timeout_seconds	120	Per-provider timeout (see note below)
db_path	~/.compare/todos.sqlite	SQLite todo store location
dedup_threshold	0.65	Fuzzy match threshold (0-1). Higher = stricter
max_file_lines	1000	Warn before sending files larger than this

Timeout note: Some models (e.g. Kimi's kimi-k2.5) are significantly slower than GPT-4o on large prompts and will time out at 60s. We default to 120s. If a provider consistently times out, try a faster model variant — for Kimi, moonshot-v1-auto is faster than kimi-k2.5 and auto-selects the right context window.

Adding providers

Any OpenAI-compatible endpoint

{
  "my_provider": {
    "enabled": true,
    "type": "openai_compat",
    "api_key": "$MY_API_KEY",
    "model": "model-name",
    "base_url": "https://api.example.com/v1"
  }
}

Works with: OpenAI, Kimi (api.moonshot.ai), Minimax (api.minimax.io), Gemini (generativelanguage.googleapis.com/v1beta/openai/), Ollama API (localhost:11434/v1), OpenRouter, Together AI, Groq, etc.

CLI subprocess model

{
  "ollama_local": {
    "enabled": true,
    "type": "cli",
    "cli_command": "ollama",
    "cli_args": ["run", "codellama"],
    "cli_parser": "text"
  }
}

cli_parser options: "text" (raw stdout), "json" (parse as JSON), "jsonl" (last complete JSON line).

Commands

In Claude Code, type any of these:

Command	What it does
/compare <issue>	Fan out to all enabled models, diff findings, save ranked todos
/compare <issue> --debate	Same as above, plus a debate round where models critique each other
/compare <issue> --providers openai,kimi	Compare specific providers only
/compare models	Show configured providers and their status
/compare status	Show all todos grouped by status (pending/in_progress/done)
/compare update <id> <status>	Change a todo's status

After /compare runs, you'll be asked whether to dispatch subagents to fix the findings in parallel. Each subagent gets one todo, implements the fix, and commits.

How it works

1. Dispatch — compare_run fans out the code + issue to all enabled providers via asyncio.gather. Providers that timeout or error are excluded, never crash the whole run.

2. Diff — compare_diff uses rapidfuzz (token sort ratio) to deduplicate findings across providers. Findings seen by 2+ providers are "shared"; the rest are "unique". Agreement rate = shared / total unique groups.

3. Debate (optional) — compare_debate sends each provider's findings to every other provider for critique. A synthesis call merges the results. Capped at 4 providers to limit API calls (N*(N-1)+1).

4. Todos — compare_todos writes ranked findings to SQLite. High severity first, then by provider count.

5. Execute — The /compare skill dispatches parallel Claude Code subagents, one per todo. Each implements the fix and commits.

MCP tools (7)

Tool	Description
compare_models	List configured providers (no API keys exposed)
compare_run	Fan out code review to providers in parallel
compare_diff	Extract unique vs shared insights with fuzzy dedup
compare_debate	Models critique each other, then synthesize
compare_todos	Write ranked findings to SQLite
compare_status	Read todos grouped by status
compare_todo_update	Update a todo's status

vs multi_mcp

multi_mcp does parallel dispatch well. compare-mcp builds the workflow layer on top:

Feature	multi_mcp	compare-mcp
Parallel dispatch	yes	yes
OpenAI-compat providers	yes	yes
CLI subprocess models	yes	yes
Debate / critique round	raw	structured + merged output
Insight diff (unique vs shared)	no	rapidfuzz dedup
Agreement rate metric	no	yes
SQLite ranked todo store	no	yes
Subagent dispatch per todo	no	yes
Git commit per fix	no	yes
CC skill + /compare	no	yes
pip install	no (git clone + make)	yes

vs Copilot CLI multi-model

Copilot CLI routes through GitHub's API proxy — no BYO keys, no Kimi/Minimax/local models. compare-mcp calls provider APIs directly: full context windows, your own rate limits, any model with an HTTP endpoint or CLI binary.

Development

git clone https://github.com/carolinacherry/compare-mcp.git
cd compare-mcp
pip install -e ".[dev]"
pytest
ruff check .