eldc 0.1.2

The fastest high-accuracy natural language detector. Compiled in C. Nito-ELDC, ELDC, ELD-C.

Efficient Language Detector - C

Efficient language detector C version (ELD-C or ELDC), is the fastest high-accuracy natural language detector.
ELDC can be compiled into a library, a command line executable, or installed as a python package with C extension.

ELD is also available in PHP (v3), Javascript (v2), and pure Python (v1 outdated). ELD-C is v3.

Making "the fastest" or most accurate language identification tool can be trivial using unlimited resources, but doing both things while being memory constrained, is what ELD-C has the edge on. It's 2x faster than Google's CLD2 (previously the fastest decent detector for the last 10 years), and 6x faster than Facebook's Fasttext. It's also more accurate than Lingua (based on the following benchmarks), and also 100x faster. ELD-C is basically a port from ELD-PHP v3.

1. ELDC Python package
2. ELDC Library
3. Command line executable
4. Benchmarks
5. Languages
6. More info

ELDC Python package

It compiles the C extension on your machine. You need a C compiler (GCC, Clang, or MSVC) and Python headers. On most Linux/macOS systems these are already present. On Windows, install Visual Studio Build Tools and ensure cl.exe is on PATH.

Installation

$ pip install eldc

How to use?

Full demo at demo_eldc_package.py

import eldc

eldc.init()

# We can set a language filter
eldc.set_languages(["en", "es", "fr"]) # also accepts string "en, es, fr"
# returns a list of the set languages ['en', 'es', 'fr']

# ISO 639-2/T output, (default iso639-1)
# eldc.set_scheme("iso639-2t")

# simple detect, returns a string with language code, or "und" for undetermined
eldc.detect("Bonjour le monde") # 'fr'

# for detect_details() we can choose up to how many scores we want
eldc.set_scores(2) # default 3, max 20

r = eldc.detect_details("Hola mundo")
print(r.language)   # 'es'
print(r.scores)  # {'es': 0.80, 'pt': 0.57}  Scores are between 0 and 1
print(r.reliable)   # True or False

ELDC Library

Compile a library for Linux .so, Windows .dll or Darwin (macOS) .dylib. To be used with your preferred programming language.
I included demo examples in the main folder for: Java, TypeScript/Node/Js, Go, Rust, .NET/C#, PHP, Ruby, and Python. (I've not tried all; Sonnet 4.6 made them)

Installation

Download repostory or clone.

git clone https://github.com/nitotm/eldc.git
cd eldc/src/eldc

• Linux

gcc -O3 -shared -fPIC -DELD_BUILD_DLL -o libeldc.so  eldc_lib.c -lm

• Windows MinGW-w64

gcc -O3 -shared -DELD_BUILD_DLL -o eldc.dll eldc_lib.c -lm -Wl,--out-implib,libeldc.a

• macOS (Darwin)

gcc -O3 -shared -fPIC -DELD_BUILD_DLL -o libeldc.dylib eldc_lib.c -lm

• Windows. Use Developer Command Prompt.

cl /O2 /LD /DELD_BUILD_DLL eldc_lib.c /Fe:eldc.dll

How to use?

Find complete demos at the root folder of this repository, for each programming language: demo_eldc_lib.py, demo_eldc_lib.ts, demo_eldc_lib.go, etc.
Here is a simple demo in PHP, as it is quite readable.

$ffi = FFI::cdef('
    typedef struct { const char *language; float score; } EldcScoreItem;
    typedef struct {
        const char   *language;
        int           reliable;
        int           n_scores;
        EldcScoreItem scores[20];
    } EldcDetectResult;

    void        eldc_init(void);
    void        eldc_close(void);
    const char *eldc_detect(const char *text);
    const char *eldc_detect_details(const char *text, EldcDetectResult *result);
    const char *eldc_set_languages(const char *codes);
    void        eldc_set_scheme(const char *scheme);
    void        eldc_set_scores(int n);
    void        eldc_set_faster(int flag);
', './libeldc.so');  // Windows: 'eldc.dll', macOS: './libeldc.dylib'

$ffi->eldc_init();

$ffi->eldc_detect("Bonjour le monde");  // string: "fr"

// detect_details() to retrieve full data
$r = $ffi->new("EldcDetectResult");
$ffi->eldc_detect_details("Bonjour le monde", FFI::addr($r));
$r->language;  // string: "fr"
$r->reliable;  // int: 1 (0 for false, 1 for true)
$r->n_scores;  // int: 3 (default, up to)
$r->scores[0]->language;  // string: "fr"
$r->scores[0]->score;  // float: 0.9016

// Return up to X scores. Default 3, max 20
$ffi->eldc_set_scores(2);  
$r2 = $ffi->new("EldcDetectResult"); 
$ffi->eldc_detect_details("Bonjour le monde", FFI::addr($r2));
$r2->n_scores; // int: 2

// Set a language subset, returns validated languages
$ffi->eldc_set_languages("en,fr,de");  // string: "en,fr,de"
$ffi->eldc_detect("Hola mundo, bonito dia");  // string: "fr"
$ffi->eldc_set_languages("");  // reset

$ffi->eldc_set_scheme("iso639-2t");  // Default "iso639-1"
$ffi->eldc_detect("Hola mundo, bonito dia");  // string: "spa"

// Cleanup
$ffi->eldc_close(); 

Command line executable

There are 2 versions, standard eld.c and multi thread eld_mt.c. You might use this executable just to try it, but its input file processing is the fastest ELD-C implementation suitable for production and heavy workloads.

Installation

Download repostory or clone.

git clone https://github.com/nitotm/eldc.git
cd eldc/src/eldc

• Linux or macOS

gcc -O3 -march=native -o eldc eld.c -lm
# Or multi thread executable
gcc -O3 -march=native -o eldc_mt eld_mt.c -lm -lpthread

• Windows MinGW-w64

gcc -O3 -o eldc.exe eld.c -lm -static
# Or multi thread executable
gcc -O3 -o eldc_mt.exe eld_mt.c -lm -lpthread -static

• Windows. Use Developer Command Prompt.

cl /O2 eld.c /Fe:eldc.exe

How to use?

If we input text (after flags), it will make a single detect; if not, it will read from stdin; one result per line.
If we use --scores or --reliable, it will return JSON, if not, a simple unquoted string with language code or und for undetected.

-h, --help              This message
    --list-languages    Print all supported codes and exit
-v, --verbose           Loading info, timing, throughput
    --faster            Uses 2x hashtable (32 MB → 64 MB), minimal speedup
-l, --languages CODES   Restrict to a subset, e.g. -l "es,en,de,fr"
                        Accepts ISO 639-1 or ISO 639-2/T codes.
-s, --scores [N]        Output compact JSON with top-N normalised [0,1] scores
                        N must be 1..20; omit N to get all 20.
                        Example: {"language":"en","scores":{"en":0.9234,...}}
-r, --reliable          Add "reliable" boolean to JSON output
    --scheme NAME       iso639-1 (default) | iso639-2t

For eld_mt.c, we also have the flag -t, --threads to limit threads -t 4

Examples: (on Windows use eldc.exe)

./eldc "Bonjour le monde"
./eldc -l "es,en,fr,de" --scheme iso639-2t "Hola mundo"
./eldc --scores --reliable "Hello world"
./eldc < corpus.txt > results.txt
./eldc --verbose

Benchmarks

ELD-C comes out as the fastest detector. For reference, with the command line executable an i7-4770 can process files at over 1M lines per second (1GB/15sec.) with only 1 thread.

I also included a multithreaded version, that can process files almost as fast as the I/O can support, with multithread an i7-4770 jumps to 4M lines per second or 1GB of text in 5 seconds (read 21M lines + classify + store results). In short, it's unnecessarily fast.

This feat would be meaningless if it weren't for the fact that it could also be one of the most accurate detectors; which it is for this benchmark. Accuracy is more benchmark dependent, but it is clearly among the most accurate detectors.

Contenders

URL	Version	Language
https://github.com/nitotm/eldc/	3.0.0	C
https://github.com/pemistahl/lingua-py	2.0.2	Python
https://github.com/facebookresearch/fastText	0.9.2	C++
https://github.com/CLD2Owners/cld2	Aug 21, 2015	C++
https://github.com/wooorm/franc	7.2.0	Javascript

Benchmarks:

• Tatoeba: 20MB, short sentences from Tatoeba, 50 languages supported by all contenders, up to 10k lines each.

• For Tatoeba, I limited all detectors to the 50 languages subset, making the comparison as fair as possible.
• Also, Tatoeba is not part of ELD training dataset (nor tuning), but it is for fasttext

• ELD Test: 10MB, sentences from the 60 languages supported by ELD, 1000 lines each. Extracted from the 60GB of ELD training data.
• Sentences: 8MB, sentences from Lingua benchmark, minus unsupported languages and Yoruba which had broken characters.
• Word pairs 1.5MB, and Single words 870KB, also from Lingua, same 53 languages.

Other notes:

• ELDC pyc is eldc python package.
• I added ELDC <file> bench to show full potential without a wrapper, ELDC <file> bench times include: file read, detect & save results.
• ELDC <file> -t 4 stands for: command line with multi thread (4 threads), ./eldc_mt < eld_test.txt > results.txt -v -t 4

Time execution benchmark: Accuracy:

• Lingua participates with 54 languages, Franc with 58.
• fasttext does not have a built-in subset option, so to show its accuracy and speed potential I made two benchmarks, fasttext-all not being limited by any subset at any test
• ^* Google's CLD2 also lacks subset option, and it's difficult to make a subset even with its option bestEffort = True, as usually returns only one language, so it has a comparative disadvantage.
• Time is normalized: (total lines * time) / processed lines

Languages

• These are the 60 supported languages for Nito-ELDC.

Amharic, Arabic, Azerbaijani (Latin), Belarusian, Bulgarian, Bengali, Catalan, Czech, Danish, German, Greek, English, Spanish, Estonian, Basque, Persian, Finnish, French, Gujarati, Hebrew, Hindi, Croatian, Hungarian, Armenian, Icelandic, Italian, Japanese, Georgian, Kannada, Korean, Kurdish (Arabic), Lao, Lithuanian, Latvian, Malayalam, Marathi, Malay (Latin), Dutch, Norwegian, Oriya, Punjabi, Polish, Portuguese, Romanian, Russian, Slovak, Slovene, Albanian, Serbian (Cyrillic), Swedish, Tamil, Telugu, Thai, Tagalog, Turkish, Ukrainian, Urdu, Vietnamese, Yoruba, Chinese

• These are the ISO 639-1 codes that include the 60 languages. Plus 'und' for undetermined
  It is the default ELD language scheme. --scheme iso639-1

am, ar, az, be, bg, bn, ca, cs, da, de, el, en, es, et, eu, fa, fi, fr, gu, he, hi, hr, hu, hy, is, it, ja, ka, kn, ko, ku, lo, lt, lv, ml, mr, ms, nl, no, or, pa, pl, pt, ro, ru, sk, sl, sq, sr, sv, ta, te, th, tl, tr, uk, ur, vi, yo, zh

• ISO 639-2/T codes (which are also valid 639-3) --scheme iso639-2t.

amh, ara, aze, bel, bul, ben, cat, ces, dan, deu, ell, eng, spa, est, eus, fas, fin, fra, guj, heb, hin, hrv, hun, hye, isl, ita, jpn, kat, kan, kor, kur, lao, lit, lav, mal, mar, msa, nld, nor, ori, pan, pol, por, ron, rus, slk, slv, sqi, srp, swe, tam, tel, tha, tgl, tur, ukr, urd, vie, yor, zho

---

More info

• ELD-C executable is 26MB, and loads a 32MB hashtable (64MB if --faster), using a total of ~55MB of memory.
• ELD-C only reads first 1000 bytes of the input string (benchmarks are fair, with all lines under), but could be modded, if you feel an increased --limit flag/option is necessary, open a discussion.
• Unlike other versions of ELD, ELD-C only comes with the 'large' database size, as that is the optimal one, but other sizes could be added.
• ELD-C is optimized for multi-detection, for single detection a B-tree would offer faster loading and lower memory usage than the current hashtable. I haven't anticipated this being the most common use case, but it could be optimized for.
• Next improvement could be a better training data set, my own "small" 60GB of data are not as clean as I wish, fineweb-2 looks good.

Donations and suggestions

If you wish to donate for open source improvements, hire me for private modifications, request alternative dataset training, or contact me, please use the following link: https://linktr.ee/nitotm