judge-llm 1.0.6

A lightweight LLM evaluation framework for comparing and testing AI providers

JUDGE LLM

A lightweight, extensible Python framework for evaluating and comparing LLM providers. Test your AI agents systematically with multi-turn conversations, cost tracking, and comprehensive reporting.

Quick Start • Features • Examples • Reports

Purpose

JUDGE LLM helps you evaluate AI agents and LLM providers by running test cases against your models and measuring:

• Response quality (exact matching, semantic similarity, ROUGE scores)
• Cost & latency (token usage, execution time, budget compliance)
• Conversation flow (tool uses, multi-turn interactions)
• Safety & custom metrics (extensible evaluation logic)

Perfect for regression testing, A/B testing providers, and ensuring production-grade quality.

Features

• Multiple Providers: Gemini, Google ADK, ADK HTTP, Mock, and custom providers with registry-based extensibility
• Built-in Evaluators: Response similarity, trajectory validation, cost/latency checks, embedding similarity, LLM-as-judge, sub-agent chain validation
• Custom Components: Create and register custom providers, evaluators, and reporters
• Registry System: Register once in defaults, use everywhere by name
• Rich Reports: Console tables, interactive HTML dashboard, JSON exports, SQLite database, plus custom reporters
• Parallel Execution: Run evaluations concurrently with configurable workers
• Quality Gates: Fail CI/CD builds when thresholds are violated (configurable)
• Config-Driven: YAML configs with smart defaults or programmatic Python API
• Default Config: Reusable configurations with component registration
• Per-Test Overrides: Fine-tune evaluator thresholds per test case
• Environment Variables: Auto-loads .env for secure API key management
• Telemetry: Optional OpenTelemetry tracing with Phoenix, Jaeger, and OTLP support

Installation

From Source

git clone https://github.com/HiHelloAI/judge-llm.git
cd judge-llm
pip install -e .

From PyPI (when published)

pip install judge-llm

With Optional Dependencies

# Install with Gemini provider support
pip install judge-llm[gemini]

# Install with Google ADK provider support
pip install judge-llm[google_adk]

# Install with dev dependencies
pip install judge-llm[dev]

# Install with OpenTelemetry support
pip install judge-llm[telemetry]

# Install with Arize Phoenix observability
pip install judge-llm[phoenix]

Setup Environment Variables

JUDGE LLM automatically loads environment variables from a .env file:

# Copy the example file
cp .env.example .env

# Edit .env and add your API keys
nano .env

.env file:

# Google Gemini API Key
GOOGLE_API_KEY=your-google-api-key-here

The .env file is automatically loaded when you import the library or run the CLI. Never commit .env to version control - it's already in .gitignore.

Quick Start

CLI Usage

# Run evaluation from config file
judge-llm run --config config.yaml

# Run with inline arguments (supports .json, .yaml, or .yml)
judge-llm run --dataset ./data/eval.yaml --provider mock --agent-id my_agent --report html --output report.html

# Validate configuration
judge-llm validate --config config.yaml

# List available components
judge-llm list providers
judge-llm list evaluators
judge-llm list reporters

# Generate dashboard from database
judge-llm dashboard --db results.db --output dashboard.html

Python API

from judge_llm import evaluate

# From config file
report = evaluate(config="config.yaml")

# Programmatic API (supports .json, .yaml, or .yml datasets)
report = evaluate(
    dataset={"loader": "local_file", "paths": ["./data/eval.yaml"]},
    providers=[{"type": "mock", "agent_id": "my_agent"}],
    evaluators=[{"type": "response_evaluator", "config": {"similarity_threshold": 0.8}}],
    reporters=[{"type": "console"}, {"type": "html", "output_path": "./report.html"}]
)

print(f"Success: {report.success_rate:.1%} | Cost: ${report.total_cost:.4f}")

Configuration

Minimal config.yaml:

dataset:
  loader: local_file
  paths: [./data/eval.json]  # Supports .json, .yaml, or .yml files

providers:
  - type: gemini
    agent_id: my_agent
    model: gemini-2.0-flash-exp

evaluators:
  - type: response_evaluator
    config: {similarity_threshold: 0.8}

reporters:
  - type: console
  - type: html
    output_path: ./report.html

Advanced config with quality gates:

agent:
  fail_on_threshold_violation: true  # Exit with error if evaluations fail (default: true)
  parallel_execution: true            # Run tests in parallel
  max_workers: 4                      # Number of parallel workers
  num_runs: 3                         # Run each test 3 times

dataset:
  loader: local_file
  paths: [./data/eval.yaml]

providers:
  - type: gemini
    agent_id: production_agent
    model: gemini-2.0-flash-exp

evaluators:
  - type: response_evaluator
    config:
      similarity_threshold: 0.85  # Minimum 85% similarity required
  - type: cost_evaluator
    config:
      max_cost_per_case: 0.05      # Maximum $0.05 per test

reporters:
  - type: database
    db_path: ./results.db  # Track results over time

Use in CI/CD:

# Fails with exit code 1 if any evaluator thresholds are violated
judge-llm run --config ci-config.yaml

# Or disable failures for monitoring
# Set fail_on_threshold_violation: false in config

Dataset File Formats:

JUDGE LLM supports both JSON and YAML formats for evaluation datasets. Use whichever format you prefer:

# Using JSON dataset
dataset:
  loader: local_file
  paths: [./data/eval.json]

# Using YAML dataset
dataset:
  loader: local_file
  paths: [./data/eval.yaml]

# Using multiple datasets (mixed formats)
dataset:
  loader: local_file
  paths:
    - ./data/eval1.json
    - ./data/eval2.yaml

# Using directory loader with pattern
dataset:
  loader: directory
  paths: [./data]
  pattern: "*.yaml"  # or "*.json" or "*.yml"

Google ADK Provider Configuration:

For agents built with Google's Agent Development Kit (ADK):

providers:
  - type: google_adk
    agent_id: my_adk_agent
    agent_metadata:
      module_path: "tool_agent.agent"  # Path to your agent module
      agent_name: "root_agent"         # Agent variable name (default: "root_agent")
      root_path: "."                   # Root path for imports (optional)

The ADK provider automatically:

• Loads your ADK agent from the specified module
• Converts between Judge LLM and ADK formats
• Validates tool usage and conversation flow
• Reports results in standard Judge LLM format

See examples/09-google-adk-agent/ for a complete working example.

ADK HTTP Provider Configuration:

For evaluating agents deployed as remote HTTP services:

providers:
  - type: adk_http
    agent_id: my_remote_agent
    endpoint_url: "http://localhost:8000/run_sse"
    auth_type: bearer          # bearer, api_key, basic, none
    timeout: 60
    app_name: "my_app"
    model: gemini-2.0-flash

evaluators:
  - type: response_evaluator
  - type: trajectory_evaluator
  - type: subagent_evaluator   # Validate agent transfer chains
  - type: llm_judge_evaluator  # LLM-as-judge quality assessment
    config:
      evaluation_type: comprehensive

See examples/10-adk-http-agent/ for a complete working example.

See the examples/ directory for complete configuration examples including default configs, custom evaluators, and advanced features.

Custom Component Registration

JUDGE LLM supports registering custom providers, evaluators, and reporters for reuse across projects.

Method 1: Register in Default Config

Create .judge_llm.defaults.yaml in your project root:

# Register custom components once
providers:
  - type: custom
    module_path: ./my_providers/anthropic.py
    class_name: AnthropicProvider
    register_as: anthropic  # ← Use this name in test configs

evaluators:
  - type: custom
    module_path: ./my_evaluators/safety.py
    class_name: SafetyEvaluator
    register_as: safety

reporters:
  - type: custom
    module_path: ./my_reporters/slack.py
    class_name: SlackReporter
    register_as: slack

Then use them by name in any test config:

# test.yaml - clean and simple!
providers:
  - type: anthropic  # ← Uses registered custom provider
    agent_id: claude

evaluators:
  - type: safety  # ← Uses registered custom evaluator

reporters:
  - type: slack  # ← Uses registered custom reporter
    config: {webhook_url: ${SLACK_WEBHOOK}}

Method 2: Programmatic Registration

from judge_llm import evaluate, register_provider, register_evaluator, register_reporter
from my_components import CustomProvider, SafetyEvaluator, SlackReporter

# Register components
register_provider("my_provider", CustomProvider)
register_evaluator("safety", SafetyEvaluator)
register_reporter("slack", SlackReporter)

# Use by name
report = evaluate(
    dataset={"loader": "local_file", "paths": ["./tests.json"]},
    providers=[{"type": "my_provider", "agent_id": "test"}],
    evaluators=[{"type": "safety"}],
    reporters=[{"type": "slack", "config": {"webhook_url": "..."}}]
)

Benefits:

• ✅ DRY - Register once, use everywhere
• ✅ Team Standardization - Share defaults across team
• ✅ Clean Configs - Test configs reference components by name
• ✅ Easy Updates - Change implementation in one place

See examples/default_config_reporters/ for complete examples.

Testing Examples

Explore 10 complete examples in the examples/ directory, from basic setup to advanced features:

Example	Description	Key Features
01-gemini-agent	Basic Gemini agent evaluation	Simple setup, response evaluation, CLI & Python API usage
02-default-config	Using default configuration files	Config merging, .judge_llm.defaults.yaml, reducing duplication
03-custom-evaluator	Creating custom evaluators	Extending BaseEvaluator, custom validation logic, registration
04-safety-long-conversation	Multi-turn safety evaluation	Long conversations, PII detection, toxicity analysis, LLM-as-judge
05-evaluator-config-override	Per-test-case evaluator overrides	Fine-grained threshold control, two-level configuration
06-database-reporter	SQLite database reporter	Historical tracking, trend analysis, SQL queries, cost monitoring
07-custom-reporter	Creating custom reporters	CSV reporter example, config-based & programmatic registration
08-default-config-reporters	Registering custom components	Register providers, evaluators, and reporters in defaults
09-google-adk-agent	Google ADK agent evaluation	ADK integration, tool usage validation, agent module loading
10-adk-http-agent	Remote ADK HTTP agent evaluation	HTTP/SSE streaming, multi-agent chains, sub-agent evaluation

Running Examples

Each example includes configuration files, datasets, and detailed instructions:

# Navigate to any example
cd examples/01-gemini-agent

# Run via CLI
judge-llm run --config config.yaml

# Or run via Python script
python run_evaluation.py

# Or use the convenience shell script
./run.sh

Example Categories

Getting Started:

• Start with 01-gemini-agent for basic usage
• Use 02-default-config to learn configuration best practices

Customization:

• 03-custom-evaluator - Build domain-specific evaluation logic
• 07-custom-reporter - Create custom output formats
• 08-default-config-reporters - Organize custom components

Advanced Features:

• 04-safety-long-conversation - Production-ready safety evaluation with LLM-as-judge
• 05-evaluator-config-override - Fine-tune evaluations per test case
• 06-database-reporter - Track metrics over time with SQL queries
• 09-google-adk-agent - Evaluate Google ADK agents seamlessly
• 10-adk-http-agent - Evaluate remote agents via HTTP with multi-agent chain validation

Built-in Components

Providers

• Gemini - Google's Gemini models (requires GOOGLE_API_KEY in .env)
• Google ADK - Google's Agent Development Kit for local agentic workflows (requires google-adk package)
• ADK HTTP - Remote ADK HTTP endpoints with SSE streaming, multi-auth, and agent chain tracking (requires httpx)
• Mock - Built-in test provider, no setup required
• Custom - Extend BaseProvider for your own LLM providers (OpenAI, Anthropic, etc.)

Evaluators

• ResponseEvaluator - Compare responses (exact, semantic similarity, ROUGE)
• TrajectoryEvaluator - Validate tool uses, conversation flow, and argument matching
• CostEvaluator - Enforce cost thresholds
• LatencyEvaluator - Enforce latency thresholds
• EmbeddingSimilarityEvaluator - Semantic similarity using embeddings (Gemini, OpenAI, sentence-transformers)
• LLMJudgeEvaluator - LLM-as-judge for relevance, hallucination, quality, and factuality assessment
• SubAgentEvaluator - Validate agent transfer chains in multi-agent orchestration systems
• Custom - Extend BaseEvaluator for custom logic (safety, compliance, etc.)

Reporters

• ConsoleReporter - Rich terminal output with colored tables
• HTMLReporter - Interactive HTML dashboard
• JSONReporter - Machine-readable JSON export
• DatabaseReporter - SQLite database for historical tracking
• Custom - Extend BaseReporter for custom formats (CSV, Slack, Datadog, etc.)

Reports & Dashboard

HTML Dashboard

Interactive web interface with:

• Sidebar: Summary metrics + execution list with color-coded status
• Main Panel: Execution details, evaluator scores, conversation history
• Features: Dark mode, responsive, self-contained (works offline)

Console Output

Rich formatted tables with live execution progress

JSON Export

Machine-readable results for programmatic analysis

SQLite Database

Persistent storage for:

• Historical trend tracking
• Regression detection
• Cost analysis over time
• SQL-based queries

# Generate dashboard from database
judge-llm dashboard --db results.db --output dashboard.html

Telemetry & Observability (OpenTelemetry)

Judge LLM includes optional OpenTelemetry instrumentation for deep observability into evaluation runs. Disabled by default with zero overhead when not enabled.

Quick Start

# Install telemetry dependencies
pip install judge-llm[telemetry]

# Run with console tracing
judge-llm run --config config.yaml --telemetry

# Run with OTLP exporter (Jaeger, Grafana Tempo, etc.)
judge-llm run --config config.yaml --telemetry --telemetry-exporter otlp

Arize Phoenix Integration

# Install Phoenix support
pip install judge-llm[phoenix]

# Start Phoenix server
pip install arize-phoenix && phoenix serve

# Run with Phoenix tracing
judge-llm run --config config.yaml --telemetry --telemetry-exporter phoenix
# Open http://localhost:6006 to view traces

Enable via YAML Config

agent:
  telemetry:
    enabled: true
    exporter: phoenix    # "console", "otlp", or "phoenix"
    endpoint: http://localhost:6006

Enable via Environment Variables

export JUDGE_LLM_TELEMETRY=true
export OTEL_EXPORTER_TYPE=phoenix
export PHOENIX_COLLECTOR_ENDPOINT=http://localhost:6006

What Gets Traced

Every evaluation creates a span tree with detailed attributes:

judge_llm.evaluate
├── judge_llm.execute_task          [per eval_case x provider x run]
│   ├── judge_llm.provider.execute  (success, cost, tokens)
│   │   ├── adk_http.create_session (HTTP status, session ID)
│   │   └── adk_http.send_and_collect (events, retries, errors)
│   └── judge_llm.evaluator.evaluate (score, passed/failed)
└── judge_llm.reporter.generate     [per reporter]

See the Telemetry Guide for complete documentation.

Development

# Setup
pip install -e ".[dev]"

# Run tests
pytest

# Format code
black judge_llm && ruff check judge_llm

Contributions welcome! Fork, create a feature branch, add tests, and submit a PR.

License

Licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 - Free for non-commercial use with attribution. See LICENSE for details.

For commercial licensing, contact the maintainers.