Skip to main content

Sure-footed refactoring achieved through experimenting

Project description

A Python library for carefully refactoring critical paths by testing in production (inspired by GitHub’s Scientist) with support for Python 2.7, 3.3+

  1. Why?

  2. Installation

  3. Getting started

  4. Adding context

  5. Ramping up

  6. Controlling comparison

  7. Raise on mismatch

  8. Publishing results

  9. Caveats

  10. Links


Some blocks of code are more critical than the rest. Laboratory helps us refactor important code paths by running experiments in production and verifying the results.

The value lies in its ability to give us a sense of confidence where there was none before. Through experimentation we immediately see if candidate code is misbehaving, and at the same time we establish a feedback loop that we can use to converge on correctness more quickly.

I’ve written a blog post if you’d like to know more: Sure-footed refactoring. The original blog post that inspired this project is worth a read too: Scientist.


Installing from pypi is recommended

$ pip install laboratory

You can also install a tagged version from Github

$ pip install

Or the latest development version

$ pip install git+

Getting started

See: Installation or pip install laboratory

With Laboratory you conduct an experiment with your known-good code as the control block and a new code branch as a candidate. Laboratory will:

  • Execute the new and the old code in a randomised order

  • Compare the return values

  • Record timing information about old & new code

  • Catch (but record!) exceptions in the new code

  • Publish all of this information

Let’s imagine you’re refactoring some authorisation code. Your existing code is working, but it’s a fragile pile of spaghetti that is becoming hard to maintain. You want to refactor, but this is important code and you simply can’t afford to get this wrong or else you risk exposing user data. Considering the state of the original code, this could be difficult to pull off, but Laboratory is here to help.

Laboratory helps us verify the correctness of our implementation even with the cornucopia of factors that make production a unique environment (bad or legacy data, heavy load, etc.)

Let’s set up an experiment to run our old (control) and new (candidate) code:

import laboratory

# set up the experiment and define control and candidate functions
experiment = laboratory.Experiment()
experiment.control(authorise_control, args=[user], kwargs={'action': action})
experiment.candidate(authorise_candidate, args=[user], kwargs={'action': action})

# conduct the experiment and return the control value
authorised = experiment.conduct()

Note that the Experiment class can also be used as a decorator if the control and candidate functions take the same arguments.

def authorise_candidate(user, action=None):
    return True

def authorise_control(user, action=None):
    return True

An experiment will always return the value of the control block.

Adding context

A lot of the time there’s going to be extra context around an experiment that’s useful to use in publishing or when verifying results. There are a couple ways to set this.

# The first is experiment-wide context, which will be set on every Observation an experiment makes
experiment = laboratory.Experiment(name='Authorisation experiment', context={'action': action})

# Context can also be set on an Observation-specific basis
experiment.control(control_func, context={'strategy': 1})
experiment.candidate(cand_func, context={'strategy': 2})

Context can be retrieved using the get_context method on Experiment and Observation instances.

class Experiment(laboratory.Experiment):
    def publish(self, result):

Ramping up

Before running a candidate code block Laboratory will call Experiment.enabled. By overriding this method we can control when the candidate code will be executed.

For example, if we wanted to enable the experiment for just 10% of calls, we could do something along these lines:

class MyExperiment(laboratory.Experiment):
    def enabled(self):
        return random.random() < 0.1

This is useful for slowly ramping up the experiment, but because we have access to the experiment context in the enabled method, we’re also able to do fancier things like enabling only for specific users.

class MyExperiment(laboratory.Experiment):
    def enabled(self):
        ctx = self.get_context()
        return ctx['user'] in user_segment

Controlling comparison

Not all data is created equal. By default laboratory compares using ==, but sometimes you may need to tweak this to suit your needs. It’s easy enough — subclass Experiment and implement the compare(control, observation) method.

class MyExperiment(Experiment):
    def compare(self, control, observation):
        return control.value['id'] == observation.value['id']

Raise on mismatch

The Experiment class accepts a raise_on_mismatch argument which you can set to True if you want Laboratory to raise an exception when the comparison returns false. This may be useful in testing, for example.

Publishing results

This data is useless unless we can do something with it. Laboratory makes no assumptions about how to do this — it’s entirely for you to implement to suit your needs. For example, timing data can be sent to graphite, and mismatches can be placed in a capped collection in redis for debugging later.

The publish method is passed a Result instance, with control and candidate data is available in Result.control and Result.candidates respectively.

class MyExperiment(laboratory.Experiment):
    def publish(self, result):
        statsd.timing('MyExperiment.control', result.control.duration)
        for o in result.candidates:
            statsd.timing('MyExperiment.%s' %, o.duration)


Because of the way Laboratory works, there are some situations in which it should not be used. Namely, any code with side effects, such as disk or database writes, or other state changes, are unsuitable as they’ll lead to duplicated writes. You could end up with buggy data or a candidate that affects the execution of the control.

You’ll also take a performance hit by running your new code in addition to the old, so be mindful of that. You should ramp an experiment up slowly and keep an eye on your metrics.


Laboratory is actively maintained by Joe Alcorn (Github, Twitter)

Project details

Download files

Download the file for your platform. If you're not sure which to choose, learn more about installing packages.

Source Distribution

laboratory-1.0.2.tar.gz (8.3 kB view hashes)

Uploaded Source

Built Distribution

laboratory-1.0.2-py2.py3-none-any.whl (9.4 kB view hashes)

Uploaded Python 2 Python 3

Supported by

AWS AWS Cloud computing and Security Sponsor Datadog Datadog Monitoring Fastly Fastly CDN Google Google Download Analytics Microsoft Microsoft PSF Sponsor Pingdom Pingdom Monitoring Sentry Sentry Error logging StatusPage StatusPage Status page