mcp-scoring-engine 0.4.0

Scoring engine for MCP server quality assessment

mcp-scoring-engine

A standalone scoring engine for evaluating the quality of Model Context Protocol (MCP) servers. Pure Python, no framework dependencies — just dataclasses, scoring logic, and network probes.

Used in production by MCP Scoreboard to grade thousands of MCP servers.

Installation

pip install mcp-scoring-engine

Quick Start

Score a server from its GitHub repo (static analysis)

from mcp_scoring_engine import ServerInfo, analyze_repo, compute_score

server = ServerInfo(
    name="my-mcp-server",
    description="A tool server for doing useful things",
    repo_url="https://github.com/owner/my-mcp-server",
)

static = analyze_repo(server.repo_url)
result = compute_score(server, static_result=static)

print(result.composite_score)  # 0–100
print(result.grade)            # "A+", "B", "D", etc.
print(result.score_type)       # "partial" (1 tier) or "full" (2+ tiers)

Probe a running server

from mcp_scoring_engine import (
    ServerInfo, probe_server, deep_probe_server, compute_score
)

# Fast health check (~10s) — connection, initialize, ping
fast = probe_server("https://my-server.example.com/mcp")
print(fast.is_reachable, fast.connection_ms)

# Deep protocol probe (~30s) — schema validation, error handling, fuzz testing
deep = deep_probe_server("https://my-server.example.com/mcp")
print(deep.tools_count, deep.schema_valid, deep.fuzz_score)

# Score with the probe results
server = ServerInfo(name="my-server", description="...", repo_url="...")
static = analyze_repo(server.repo_url)
result = compute_score(server, static_result=static, deep_probe=deep)
print(result.grade)

Probe a stdio server

from mcp_scoring_engine import probe_server_stdio, deep_probe_server_stdio

fast = probe_server_stdio(["npx", "-y", "@modelcontextprotocol/server-memory"])
deep = deep_probe_server_stdio(["python", "-m", "my_mcp_server"])

Classify a server

from mcp_scoring_engine import classify_server, ServerInfo

server = ServerInfo(
    name="stripe-mcp",
    description="MCP server for Stripe payment processing",
    repo_url="https://github.com/stripe/stripe-mcp",
)

category, targets = classify_server(server)
print(category)  # "finance"
print(targets)   # ["Stripe"]

Detect red flags

from mcp_scoring_engine import detect_flags, ServerInfo

server = ServerInfo(
    name="sketchy-server",
    description="A MCP server",
    repo_url="",
    remote_endpoint_url="http://localhost:3000/mcp",
)

flags = detect_flags(server)
for flag in flags:
    print(f"[{flag.severity}] {flag.label}: {flag.description}")
    # [critical] No Source Code: No repository URL or source link provided
    # [warning] Staging Artifact: Endpoint URL contains localhost or staging reference

Architecture

The engine evaluates servers across three data tiers:

Tier	Source	What it measures
Tier 1 — Static Analysis	GitHub repo	Schema completeness, description quality, documentation, maintenance pulse, dependency health, license clarity, version hygiene
Tier 2 — Protocol Probe	Live server	Connection health, tool schema validation, error handling, fuzz resilience, auth discovery
Tier 3 — Reliability	Rolling window	Uptime percentage, p50/p95 latency

The composite score is a weighted blend of five categories:

Category	Weight
Schema & Docs	25%
Protocol Compliance	20%
Reliability	20%
Maintenance	15%
Security	20%

Score types:

• partial — Only 1 data tier available. Numeric score but no letter grade.
• full — 2+ data tiers. Graded A+ through F.

API Reference

Core

Function	Description
compute_score(server, static_result?, deep_probe?, reliability?)	Compute weighted composite score → ScoreResult
score_to_grade(score)	Convert 0–100 → letter grade (A+, A, B, C, D, F)
classify_server(server)	Categorize a server → (category, target_platforms)
detect_flags(server, context?)	Detect red flags → list[Flag]
generate_badges(server, static_result?, deep_probe?, reliability?, flags?)	Generate display badges → dict

Probes

Function	Description
probe_server(url)	Fast health check over HTTP → FastProbeResult
probe_server_stdio(command)	Fast health check over stdio → FastProbeResult
deep_probe_server(url)	Full protocol probe over HTTP → DeepProbeResult
deep_probe_server_stdio(command)	Full protocol probe over stdio → DeepProbeResult
analyze_repo(repo_url)	Static analysis of GitHub repo → StaticAnalysis
compute_reliability_score(data)	Score from uptime + latency → int

Types

All inputs and outputs are plain dataclasses:

• ServerInfo — Input server metadata (name, description, repo_url, etc.)
• ScoreResult — Complete scoring output (composite_score, grade, category scores, flags, badges)
• FastProbeResult — Health check results (is_reachable, timing)
• DeepProbeResult — Protocol compliance results (schema, error handling, fuzz)
• StaticAnalysis — Repo analysis results (7 metric scores + GitHub metadata)
• ReliabilityData — Pre-computed reliability metrics (uptime, latency)
• Flag — Red flag (key, severity, label, description)
• Badge — Display badge (key, label, level)

License

MIT