pytest-failure-instrumentation
Most test failures explain themselves. A pytest_runtest_makereport gives you
an assertion, a traceback and a node id, and there is nothing left to
investigate.
The failures that happen outside the call phase explain nothing. A worker is killed, a run wedges, workers disagree about which tests exist, pytest raises inside its own machinery — and what reaches your reporting is a placeholder string, a line in a log, or nothing at all. This plugin records what those failures cannot say for themselves, works out whose code is responsible, and hands you one structured incident per problem.
[worker_death] NATIVE_CRASH severity=critical owner=product
blamed on engine.py:6 in native_call
in flight test_crashes.py::test_crashes phase=call started=1 finished=0
· died while running test_crashes.py::test_crashes (call)
· exit status -11 - SIGSEGV: segmentation fault in native code (pid 805, via waitid)
· the worker wrote a stack before dying
· segmentation fault in native code
The problem
When a pytest-xdist worker dies, this is the whole report:
[gw7] node down: Not properly terminated
An OOM kill, a segfault in a C extension and a stray os._exit(1) are
indistinguishable at that point. Not because nobody bothered to print the
difference — because by the time anything can ask, the difference is gone.
There are three independent reasons, and all three have to be worked around
separately.
1. The cause never leaves the process. SIGSEGV and SIGKILL end a process
without running any Python. No finally, no atexit, no __del__, no
pytest_sessionfinish. Whatever the worker knew about what it was doing, it
knew only in memory, and that memory is gone. Anything you want to know
afterwards has to have been written down before — while the run was healthy
and the cost of writing it lands on every passing test.
2. The exit status is read and thrown away. The kernel keeps one number
that separates all these cases, and the parent process is the only thing
allowed to read it. execnet does read it — Group.terminate calls
gw._io.wait() in execnet/multi.py — and discards the return value. Nothing
in xdist asks for it either.
3. There is no field to put it in. In xdist/workermanage.py,
process_from_remote handles the channel closing: it asks execnet for a remote
error, and when there is none — because the remote never got to send anything —
substitutes a literal string:
err = "Not properly terminated" # lost connection?
That string is then passed to pytest_testnodedown(node, error) as the error.
The hook is not withholding the cause. By the time it fires, the placeholder is
genuinely all that exists.
Why you never see a MemoryError
The most common way a worker dies is also the one Python is least able to
report. On Linux, malloc returning successfully is not a promise that the
memory exists — overcommit hands out address space and resolves it on first
touch. There is no allocation failure for CPython to raise MemoryError from.
The process is killed later, from outside, with SIGKILL, which cannot be
caught, blocked or handled.
And the exit status is -9 for all of it: the kernel OOM killer, a cgroup
limit, a cancelled CI job, a kill -9 from a stray script. There is no
distinct code for "out of memory". The only in-process evidence that separates
them is the cgroup v2 memory.events oom_kill counter, which is why
OOM_KILLED is claimed only when that counter moved during this run, and
SIGKILLED — "something killed it, and here is what that could have been" —
when it did not.
The failures that reach no hook at all
Worker death at least fires a hook. Three others do not.
A worker that stalls. pytest_testnodedown needs a dead process; a wedged
one is alive. And the controller hears from a worker only when a phase
completes, so from outside, a twenty-minute test and a deadlock are the same
event: nothing. The run does not fail — it never ends, and CI kills the job an
hour later with no artifact naming a test.
Workers that collected different tests. xdist notices, writes a unified diff per differing worker into its own log, and aborts. Nothing structured reaches a hook. With sixty workers and one odd node that is fifty-nine complete diffs, every one of them naming the majority as the deviation.
An internal error. pytest sets ExitCode.INTERNAL_ERROR, which is not in
summary_exit_codes in _pytest/terminal.py — so pytest_terminal_summary
never fires for it. Under xdist it is worse: a worker's internal error is
relayed to the controller as a flat string and re-raised there, so the
INTERNALERROR> block you read names xdist's frame, not the failure.
Who this is for
You ship a library into other people's test suites. Their run dies and the
bug report names your package. Nothing in the output can confirm or refute it,
and "cannot reproduce" is not an answer anyone accepts. owner is the field
that settles it — product, third-party, customer-code or runtime — and
it comes from a stack, not from a guess.
You own CI for a large suite. Runs fail with no test named. Was that the
OOM killer, or the runner getting reclaimed mid-job? -9 is identical either
way, and the answer decides whether you buy more memory or file a ticket with
your CI vendor.
Your suite hangs sometimes. Nothing fails, the job times out, and there is
no evidence at all because the process that would produce it is the one that is
stuck. worker_stall names the test, says whether the thread is blocked or the
whole process is frozen, and prints the stack of the thread actually stuck.
You run enough workers that they disagree. A conftest keyed on an environment variable, a machine-dependent skip, a plugin that collects conditionally. The run aborts and the reason is buried in N−1 diffs.
You are collecting failures across machines you do not control.
fingerprint groups recurrences so one defect on twelve workers is one row
with a count, and capabilities records what each machine could measure — so a
missing memory figure on a customer's Windows box reads as "unmeasurable here"
rather than "fine".
A worked example: xdist #1362
A worker dies in the window after it has sent its collection but before
scheduling begins, while a second worker is still collecting. The stale entry
in registered_collections is never cleaned up, and the run dies with a
KeyError naming an object rather than a problem
(pytest-dev/pytest-xdist#1362).
This is what the plugin reports for it — two incidents, because two things went wrong:
[worker_death] SIGKILLED severity=needs-triage owner=unknown
no test in flight started=0 finished=0
· died before running any test (startup or collection)
· exit status -9 - SIGKILL: uncatchable kill (OOM killer or external kill) (pid 21780, via waitid)
· resident memory 31 MB at last checkpoint
· SIGKILL with no cgroup OOM event: a host-level OOM killer, a container or CI cancellation, or an external kill
[internal_error] INTERNAL_ERROR severity=high owner=runtime run-ending
blamed on loadscope.py:275 in _assign_work_unit
KeyError: <WorkerController gw1>
· raised on the controller itself and captured first-hand
· raised above informational: a framework-owned defect that ended the run - no test is at fault, so nothing else will surface it
owner=runtime is the load-bearing part. No test is at fault and no worker is
at fault, so nothing else in the run will ever surface this — which is exactly
why it is the one case where a framework defect is raised above
informational.
Install
pip install pytest-failure-instrumentation
It registers itself as a pytest11 entry point. Implement one hook to receive
what it finds:
# conftest.py, or your own plugin
def pytest_failure_incident(incident):
database.save(incident.model_dump())
alerts.send(str(incident))
Tell it which packages are yours, so a failing frame in your code can be told from one in a dependency or in the customer's own tests:
[pytest]
failure_packages = yourcore, yourcore_ext
failure_product_version = 4.2.0
Without the hook it still writes its evidence to .pytest-failures/.
Disable it entirely with -p no:failure_instrumentation.
Installing it from your own framework
If you ship a test framework rather than consume one, ini is the wrong place for these settings. Your packages, your artifact directory and your build id are things your framework already knows, and an ini block every consuming team has to copy — and keep in step with you — is a migration that never finishes.
Call install from your plugin instead:
# yourframework/pytest_plugin.py
from pytest_failure_instrumentation import install
def pytest_configure(config):
install(config,
packages=deployment.owned_packages,
directory=deployment.artifact_dir,
product_version=deployment.version,
run_id=ci.build_id)
Keyword arguments layer on top of whatever ini said, so a team that has set
failure_stall_seconds keeps it. Passing a whole Settings instead replaces
ini entirely, for when your framework owns the configuration outright:
from pytest_failure_instrumentation import Settings, install
install(config, Settings(packages=("yourcore",), stall_seconds=600))
Settings has a default for every field, coerces a list of packages and a
string path to what it needs, and enforces its own invariants — so a
hand-built one cannot skip a floor that a resolved one obeys.
Three things this handles for you:
Load order. A conftest's pytest_configure runs before this plugin's, and
a plugin loaded as an entry point runs after it. Registration here is
trylast and only claims what nobody has installed, so your settings win
either way.
Workers. A worker is a separate process. Settings you computed in Python do
not exist there and your framework's code may not even be loaded — so whatever
is in force is pushed down through workerinput, and a worker prefers it over
anything it could read itself. run_id travels with it, which is what lets a
build id group a whole run's incidents.
Turning auto-registration off. -p no:failure_instrumentation skips the
entry point entirely; install puts back the hookspec so pytest_failure_incident
still reaches its implementers. Note that it also skips pytest_addoption, so
failure_* ini keys become unknown config options — which is the point if your
framework owns the settings, and a reason to leave the entry point enabled and
just call install if it does not.
install is idempotent and returns the settings in force. A second call keeps
the first one's and warns rather than silently losing to it;
installed_settings(config) reads them back. Like everything else here it
warns instead of raising — the one exception is a misspelled setting name,
which is your bug and is worth an error rather than a run that quietly
attributes nothing.
What you get
incident is a pydantic model, one class per kind, discriminated on
incident.kind. A segfault's resident memory and a run summary's exit code
have nothing to say to each other, so they are not fields of the same object:
kind |
Model | Raised on |
|---|---|---|
worker_death |
WorkerDeathIncident |
needs xdist |
worker_stall |
WorkerStallIncident |
needs xdist |
collection_mismatch |
CollectionMismatchIncident |
needs xdist |
internal_error |
InternalErrorIncident |
any run |
run_summary |
RunSummaryIncident |
any run |
The last two are not distributed problems, so the plugin registers whether or
not you run under xdist and a plain pytest gets both.
They share verdict, confidence, severity, owner, fingerprint,
run_id, worker and evidence. str(incident) is the alert text — every
block quoted in this README is what it prints. A stored row comes back as the
model it was written from, and the union is a schema you can migrate a table
against:
from pytest_failure_instrumentation.incidents import registry
incident = registry.parse(json.loads(row)) # -> WorkerDeathIncident, ...
registry.json_schema()
The stack is in the payload but out of str(incident), because forty
frames turn a readable incident into a wall and whether they belong in an alert
is your call. incident.raw_stack() returns them as lines whatever the kind is;
top_frame and blamed_frame are the two already parsed, each with file,
line, function, module and owner.
What you get is the deepest frames of one thread from the most recent dump —
the other threads in a worker are this plugin's own heartbeat and execnet's
receiver, and reporting those blames the instrumentation. It is capped (40
frames for a death, 14 for a stall, 4000 characters for an internal error) and
a cut stack ends with ... and N more frames rather than pretending to be
whole. The complete dump stays in <worker>.crash on the runner.
def pytest_failure_incident(incident):
body = str(incident)
frames = incident.raw_stack()
if frames:
body += "\n\n" + "\n".join(frames)
alerts.send(body)
owner is the field that settles arguments — product, third-party,
customer-code, runtime, or unknown. It comes from walking outward past
runtime frames to the first one that belongs to somebody: the deepest frame is
usually ctypes.string_at, which tells nobody anything. A stack with no owned
frame at all is not unknown — it is a positive finding that the framework
itself failed.
severity follows from ownership rather than from how loud the failure
was, so a customer's segfaulting test does not page you. The exception is a
framework defect that ends the run, above.
fingerprint is stable across runs and excludes worker id, pid and
timings, so one defect on twelve workers is one incident with a count.
capabilities says what the machine could measure, so an absent figure is
never read as a healthy one.
suspect_owner is kept apart from owner on purpose. When no stack names
anybody, the test that was in flight is a lead worth recording — but a guess
must never sit in the column a reader takes for a finding.
Handing one to an agent
An incident is written to be read without context, which is most of what an LLM
triaging a CI failure lacks. .claude/skills/reading-failure-incidents/SKILL.md
is that context in one file: the anatomy of the alert text, what each shared
field licenses a reader to conclude, the verdicts per kind, and the handful of
places where the text is a summary and the payload is the number — so an agent
reports what the incident found rather than what a -9 looks like.
Verdicts
A worker died
| Verdict | Told apart by |
|---|---|
OOM_KILLED |
-9 and the cgroup OOM counter moved |
SIGKILLED |
-9, counter flat — host OOM, CI cancellation, external kill |
NATIVE_CRASH |
SIGSEGV/SIGABRT/SIGBUS/SIGILL/SIGFPE, or a Windows NTSTATUS |
SIGNAL_<n> |
SIGTERM/SIGINT/SIGHUP — a request to stop, not a defect |
SELF_EXIT |
any exit code with no signal, 0 included — a worker that left the run was not asked to |
PROBABLY_SIGNALLED |
exit code 128–191, a wrapper ate the signal |
UNKNOWN |
no status obtainable (remote gateway) |
A worker stalled
Silence proves nothing on its own: the controller hears from a worker only when a phase completes, so a twenty-minute test and a deadlock look identical from outside. What separates them is the worker's own heartbeat, which carries CPU time.
| Verdict | Heartbeat | CPU | Means |
|---|---|---|---|
STALLED_BLOCKED |
alive | none | the test thread is waiting on something that is not coming |
STALLED_FROZEN |
stopped | — | native code is holding the GIL, or the process is stopped |
STALLED_SILENT |
never ran | — | the watchdog is off, so there is no passive evidence either way |
| (not reported) | alive | burning | slow, not stuck |
The verdict is reached from beats already on disk. A stack is asked for afterwards, once the decision is made, because asking a wedged process a question can change its answer — see below.
Workers collected different tests
| Verdict | Means |
|---|---|
COLLECTION_MEMBERSHIP_DIFFERS |
a test exists on one machine and not another |
COLLECTION_ORDER_DIFFERS |
same tests, different sequence — fatal too, since xdist addresses tests by position |
COLLECTION_PARAMETERS_UNSTABLE |
same tests, different parameter values — a parametrize that is not deterministic |
Sixty workers never produce sixty collections. They produce two or three variants, so this reports one row per variant, measured against the largest:
[collection_mismatch] COLLECTION_MEMBERSHIP_DIFFERS severity=needs-triage owner=unknown run-ending
no stack; suspect customer-code (owner of a module the workers disagreed about (test_collect.py))
2 workers produced 2 different collections
baseline: 1 worker collected 3 tests, and everything below is measured against that list
1 worker is missing 1 test, in test_collect.py (gw1)
- test_collect.py::test_two
whole collections written to .pytest-failures; the difference above travels in the incident
· xdist addresses tests by position rather than by id, so any difference between the lists is fatal - a reordering as much as a missing test
· the initial collections disagreed, so the run was aborted
At sixty workers it stays the same shape, because the row count follows the number of variants rather than the number of workers:
58 workers produced 3 different collections
baseline: 55 workers collected 300 tests, and everything below is measured against that list
2 workers are missing 1 test, in test_payments.py (gw41, gw58)
- test_payments.py::test_case_017
1 worker has 6 extra tests, in test_legacy.py (gw17)
+ test_legacy.py::test_extra_0
+ test_legacy.py::test_extra_1
+ test_legacy.py::test_extra_2
and 3 more
Read it as: how many distinct opinions existed, which workers held each, and how the minority differs from the majority. Magnitude leads each line and identity follows, samples use diff notation, and a truncated sample always says how much it withheld — a sample that looks like the whole story is worse than no sample at all.
The whole difference travels in the payload, not just the three ids the
text prints. missing and extra carry every differing node id, up to 500 per
side, with missing_count and extra_count as the true totals so you can see
whether that cap was reached. The distinction matters: a collection is
unbounded — sixty workers times fifty thousand node ids is hundreds of
megabytes — but a difference is almost always one test or one module's worth.
Only the digest is held per worker, and the whole collections are written to
collection-<digest>.txt for whoever still has the machine. That file is on a
runner which may be gone by the time anyone reads the alert, which is exactly
why the difference itself does not live there.
An order difference instead reports where the two lists first disagree, which is the one fact a unified diff of a reordered list destroys.
A parametrize whose values are drawn at collection time — random, a
timestamp, an unordered set — gives every worker a different id for the same
test, and reported as membership that reads as thousands of tests appearing and
disappearing. It is caught by asking a second question: are these the same
tests once the parameters are stripped from the ids? When they are, the report
names the parametrized tests responsible, drops the per-variant rows — which
would otherwise be one near-identical block per worker — and prints what each
of a few workers actually collected:
[collection_mismatch] COLLECTION_PARAMETERS_UNSTABLE severity=needs-triage run-ending
6 workers produced 6 different collections
the tests are the same on every worker - only the parameter values differ, so these are not tests appearing and disappearing
test_billing.py::test_invoice
gw0 collected acct-1791, acct-3471, acct-6305, acct-7468
gw1 collected acct-2186, acct-2542, acct-6991, acct-9779
gw2 collected acct-1614, acct-1950, acct-4517, acct-9313
compare those values: a parametrize evaluated at collection time - a random number, a timestamp, an unordered set, a call to something live - gives every worker a different id for the same test, and xdist requires the ids to match
The values are the diagnosis. Naming the test says where to look; three rows of disjoint account ids say a fetch is running at collection time, and three rows of floating-point noise say a random number is. Neither is apparent from one worker's list, which is the only thing xdist ever shows you.
That case is also why full id lists are held for only the first few variants.
"A handful of variants" is the assumption the whole design rests on, and
unstable ids turn it into one variant per worker. Past that limit a variant is
reported as not compared rather than diffed against a list nobody kept —
comparing two absent lists reports "the same tests in a different order", which
is a finding invented out of missing data.
A mismatch is run-ending usually, not always: xdist aborts when the initial
collections disagree, but silently drops a worker that registers a differing
collection after scheduling has begun. The run then continues one worker short,
and run_ending reflects which of the two happened.
How it knows
A fixed-size state file. Which test and phase is open right now is written
to a fixed-size slot with os.pwrite — one syscall, no append, no growth, and a
file that is the same size after a million tests as after one. That is what
separates "died in teardown" from "died mid-call": pytest's own logfinish
fires only after the whole protocol, so it cannot tell them apart. The slot is
5 KiB, holding a node id of around 4950 characters whole — past any real one by
an order of magnitude, since a path, a class, a test name and a couple of
content hashes together use a twentieth of it. The size is close to free: one
write of one buffer costs the same syscall from 256 bytes to 8 KiB, and 5 KiB
per worker is 320 KiB across a 64-way run. An id longer than that gives up its
middle, never the record: truncating the encoded record leaves it
unparseable, which costs the reader
the phase and the counters as well and reports a worker that died mid-call as
one that died before running anything. The middle goes rather than the tail
because both ends carry something the other does not — the head is the module
attribution reads, and the tail is where a parametrize puts the value saying
which case this was.
The exit status, taken from the OS. Where a Popen object survives, its
return code. Otherwise waitid(P_PID, pid, WEXITED | WNOWAIT | WNOHANG) —
WNOWAIT reads the status without consuming it, so execnet's own reaping
still works afterwards and nothing is broken by looking. Only a parent may do
this, which is why it happens on the controller, and why a remote gateway
honestly reports UNKNOWN rather than guessing. macOS does not expose
os.waitid at all and falls back to the Popen object. capabilities.exit_status
records which mechanism this machine has; exit_status_source on the incident
records which one actually answered — so a figure is never read as having come
from a mechanism that was never used. On Windows the code is normalised to its
unsigned form first: an NTSTATUS is above 2³¹, so 0xC000013A arrives signed
or unsigned depending on who answered — and a negative status means "killed by
signal N" to everything downstream.
faulthandler, pointed at a per-worker file. pytest's own faulthandler
plugin enables at configure time with trylast, aimed at shared stderr where
every worker's output interleaves. This claims the handler back afterwards, in
pytest_sessionstart. Its C handler is async-signal-safe and writes while the
GIL is held — which is the case that matters, since native code holding the
GIL is exactly what a frozen worker looks like.
Separate dump files. A fatal dump goes to <worker>.crash; the slow-test
watchdog's goes to <worker>.slow, and the frozen-interpreter fallback's to
<worker>.frozen. They are the same shape and only
the banner separates them — Fatal Python error against Timeout (…) — and a
watchdog dump is written by tests that go on to pass. Sharing one file made
"a stack exists" ambiguous, and on the Windows path where the dump is the only
thing distinguishing abort() from os._exit(3), ambiguous means a slow test
that passed can be reported as the crash that killed the worker, blamed on
whatever that stack happened to be doing.
Choosing the right dump, and the right thread inside it. Two things have to be picked here, and getting either wrong blames code that was not running.
A file holds as many dumps as were written to it, and the crash file accumulates: an on-demand stack taken while a worker was merely stalled precedes the fatal dump that ends it. The dump that describes the present is the last one. The watchdog's file holds only ever one, because each dump is written beside it and renamed into place — a reader that caught it mid-write would get the threads faulthandler had reached and not the one running the test.
Within a dump, all_threads=True means every thread is present, and the first
printed in a pytest worker is this plugin's own heartbeat thread; the second is
execnet's receiver. Reporting the first section would blame the instrumentation
for the failure it came to explain. The section reported is the one the fault
or signal reached (Current thread), else the one carrying pytest's runtest
protocol, else anything that is not ours. Current thread is skipped when it
is ours: the watchdog's dump is taken by the heartbeat thread, so
faulthandler labels that one current, and believing the label reported the
heartbeat as the frozen test.
Saying how old a stack is. A stack is evidence about a moment, and the
frames look the same whether they were taken just now or left behind four
minutes ago. A stall that could be probed reports a current stack; one that
falls back to the watchdog's file says stack written 47s ago by the slow-test watchdog, not taken just now, and carries stack_age_seconds. A death reports
crash_stack_age_seconds alongside, so a dump that predates the death reads as
the context it is rather than as the crash.
A watchdog on a cadence, written by the heartbeat thread. A test still
running after failure_slow_test_seconds has its stack written for it, and
keeps having it rewritten every interval, so whatever is on disk is at most one
interval old. That bound is the point: on Windows nothing can ask a live
process for a stack, so this is the only one a stalled worker will ever have.
The clock starts at setup and stops at the end of teardown, so a fixture
blocking on a container and a finalizer blocking on a connection are covered as
well as the test body — those are the commonest real hangs there are, and the
state slot has always told them apart. Once for the whole test rather than per
phase, or a test that spent most of the interval in setup and the rest in the
call would never reach it. The default is 20 seconds, and the file is dropped
when the test ends, so only the running test's stack is ever on disk (about
5 KB) and a healthy suite leaves nothing.
The obvious design instead has the controller signal a stalled worker and let
faulthandler answer. It has two flaws: Windows has no SIGUSR1 and os.kill
there cannot deliver one, and on POSIX the signal perturbs the subject —
PEP 475 makes Python retry on EINTR, but a C extension blocked in a raw
syscall need not, so it returns early and the stall being measured disappears.
The signal path remains as an extra, for asking an already-diagnosed worker for
a fresher stack.
The next design, and what this was until it was measured, is
faulthandler.dump_traceback_later(repeat=True). It needs no signal and works
on Windows, and it dumps even while native code holds the GIL — but it dumps
from a C thread that does not hold the GIL, walking every other thread's
frames while those threads push and pop them. A dump landing while the
interpreter is executing rather than blocked reads a frame being torn down, and
the worker segfaults. Over a suite whose tests were four times the cadence
long, that killed the worker in 10 runs out of 10, against 0 with the repeat
turned off; it left the dump ending mid-frame with a nonsense line number, and
the crash file empty because the fault was inside the dumper. Instrumentation
that crashes what it is watching is worse than no instrumentation, so the
cadence is driven from the heartbeat thread instead, in Python, holding the
GIL — nothing else can be mutating what is being walked.
A fallback for the one stack a Python thread cannot take. When native code
holds the GIL, no Python thread runs and the watchdog above writes nothing.
That is the case the C timer exists for, and also the case that makes it
dangerous — so it is armed such that it can only fire when it is safe. Every
heartbeat pushes its deadline out by three intervals, so while Python runs at
all the deadline is always in the future and the timer never fires; when three
beats in a row are missed it fires once, and by then nothing is executing for
it to trip over. Missing beats for that long has one realistic cause: a thread
holding the GIL and running C. A main thread running Python releases the GIL
every few milliseconds, and a machine loaded badly enough to starve a daemon
thread for three intervals would starve the timer's own thread with it. The
dump goes to <worker>.frozen, because it means something the watchdog's does
not — not "this test is slow" but "this process stopped responding" — and the
incident says which file its stack came out of in stack_source.
A heartbeat carrying CPU time. One line every five seconds per worker,
bounded by wall-clock rather than by how many tests run. time.process_time()
in each beat is what turns silence into a verdict: alive with no CPU is
blocked, stopped is frozen, alive and burning is a slow test that must be
reported as nothing at all.
Evidence written before it is needed. Every mechanism above puts its output on disk during the healthy part of the run, because a process that is about to be killed gets no warning. The controller reads files, never the corpse.
Cost
A passing test must cost as close to nothing as possible, because that is the overwhelming majority of what runs.
- Per test: six fixed-size writes to a file that never grows — two per phase,
one as it opens and one as it closes, which is what separates "died in
teardown" from "died mid-call" — plus two clock reads. No append log, no
/procread, no allocation tracking. - Per test that outlives
failure_slow_test_seconds(measured setup through teardown): one ~5 KB stack dump every interval, written and renamed by the heartbeat thread, and an unlink when the test ends. Nothing accumulates across tests, and nothing is written for a test that finishes in time. - Per 5 seconds, per worker: one heartbeat carrying CPU time and resident memory. Per second, per worker: two deadline comparisons and a timer rearm, which is why the first stack of a wedged test does not wait for a beat.
- Off by default:
tracemalloc(needed to attribute an OOM kill to a source line) and the live-object census — walking the heap on a worker near its ceiling is exactly the instrumentation that makes things worse. - pydantic is imported on the controller, and only when xdist is active. A worker never loads it, so nothing about the per-test path changed when the payload became typed.
- Nothing in the reporting path may raise. A failure while gathering an
incident degrades it to what survived, because an exception in a reporting
hook becomes an
INTERNALERRORthat ends the customer's run.
Settings
| Setting | Default | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
failure_packages |
— | Your top-level packages, for attribution |
failure_directory |
.pytest-failures |
Where evidence is written |
failure_watchdog |
true |
Memory and liveness sampling |
failure_heartbeat_interval |
5.0 |
Seconds between liveness beats (floor 1.0) |
failure_tracemalloc_depth |
0 |
1 names the allocating line for OOM attribution |
failure_object_census |
false |
Count live objects at a high-water mark |
failure_high_water_mb |
auto | Memory mark for a snapshot; defaults to a share of the discovered limit |
failure_memory_limit_mb |
0 |
Soft cap (POSIX) turning an OOM kill into a MemoryError |
failure_slow_test_seconds |
20 |
How often a running test refreshes its stack (setup through teardown; needs failure_watchdog) |
failure_stall_seconds |
300 |
Silence before a stall is assessed |
failure_stack_probe |
true |
Ask a diagnosed stalled worker for a fresh stack (POSIX) |
failure_slow_test_seconds and failure_stall_seconds are not independent.
The stack a stalled worker is reported with is whatever the watchdog last
wrote, so the cadence has to have fired before the stall is assessed — a stall
judged sooner is judged with no stack at all, and on Windows that is every
stall. Neither is clamped, but an inverted pair warns.
failure_memory_limit_mb is worth a note: an RLIMIT_AS cap makes the
allocation fail inside the process, so you get a MemoryError with a
traceback and a node id instead of an uncatchable kill with neither. It costs
you a hard ceiling per worker, which is why it is opt-in.
Platform coverage
| Capability | Linux | macOS | Windows |
|---|---|---|---|
| Test in flight, phase, exit status | yes | yes | yes |
| Crash stack | yes | yes | yes |
| Stack from a slow or hung test | yes | yes | yes |
| Current memory | procfs | psutil, else peak only | psapi |
| Container limit, OOM counter | yes | n/a | n/a — no OOM killer |
| On-demand stack from a stalled worker | yes | yes | no |
Two Windows differences are worth knowing about, because they change what you will see rather than how it is reported.
ctypes wraps every foreign function call in structured exception handling, so
an access violation raised through ctypes comes back as an OSError and the
worker survives it. A fault inside a real C extension still ends the process —
but the reproduction that segfaults a worker on Linux may simply fail a test on
Windows.
And a Windows process that dies from a fault reports an NTSTATUS as its exit
code rather than a signal, while abort() reports plain 3 — the same code a
deliberate os._exit(3) gives. What separates a crash from a clean exit there
is whether a dump was written, not the exit status, which is why the crash
stack is evidence in its own right rather than a decoration on the verdict.
psutil is never required, only ever an upgrade: pip install pytest-failure-instrumentation[psutil].
Tests
pip install -e ".[test]"
pytest
The integration tests run a real pytest in a subprocess through pytester,
crash or wedge a worker for real, and read back what the plugin raised — so
they exercise the mechanism rather than a mock of it. Every one of them also
round-trips its incidents through registry.parse and asserts model_dump()
equals the stored row, which makes the payload contract a property of every
scenario rather than a test of its own.
CI runs the suite on Linux, macOS and Windows across Python 3.9–3.13 — every
platform path in the table above is executed on the platform it was written
for. The
probes are platform code — procfs, psapi, waitid, GetExitCodeProcess,
cgroup counters — and none of the Windows or macOS paths can be exercised on a
Linux runner, which is the whole reason the matrix exists. Two axes matter as
much as the operating system, so each gets its own job:
- without
psutil, which is what most people actually have. Every probe has to degrade to a declared "unavailable" rather than to a wrong number. - without
pytest-xdist, wherepytest_testnodedownhas no hookspec at all and an unspecced hookimpl is a registration error — the failure mode that once made a plainpytestrun report nothing. - against the declared minimums,
pytest==7.0.1on Python 3.9. Every other job installs whatever is newest, so a hook signature or an ini type that arrived later would pass all of them and fail on a user's pinned pytest.
ruff and mypy run as their own job, and fail first because they are cheap.
The source carries # noqa and # type: ignore markers, which are only worth
writing if something reads them.
Two of the tests are about the plugin rather than about a failure: a run whose evidence directory cannot be created has to keep running, and a directory shared with somebody else's artifacts has to come out of a run with those artifacts still in it. A reporting tool that ends a run, or eats a file, has cost more than the failure it came to explain.
Releasing
Tag the commit and the rest runs itself:
git tag v0.2.0 && git push origin v0.2.0
The tag is the only input. .github/workflows/release.yml builds the sdist and
wheel, refuses to continue if the tag disagrees with the version in
pyproject.toml, installs the built wheel on Linux, macOS and Windows and
runs the whole suite against it, publishes to PyPI, and then creates the GitHub
release with the artifacts attached.
The wheel is tested rather than the checkout because this plugin is one entry
point. If packaging drops it the import still succeeds, the suite still passes,
and nothing is instrumented at all — the one failure mode a green test run
cannot rule out. So the release explicitly asserts the entry point exists and
that the package under test came from site-packages.
Credentials
There is no API token to create and no secret to add to the repository.
Publishing uses trusted publishing:
PyPI verifies this workflow's OIDC identity at upload time, so nothing
long-lived exists to leak or rotate. GITHUB_TOKEN is supplied by Actions
automatically.
What it does need is configuration, once, on each side.
On PyPI — Your account → Publishing. The project does not exist there yet, so this is an "Add a new pending publisher", not a setting on an existing project; a pending publisher is how a first upload is authorised for a name nobody has claimed. It becomes a normal publisher after that first release.
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| PyPI project name | pytest-failure-instrumentation |
| Owner | Heknon |
| Repository name | pytest-failure-instrumentation |
| Workflow name | release.yml |
| Environment name | pypi |
On GitHub — Settings → Environments → New environment, named pypi.
Under it, tick Required reviewers and add yourself. That is the manual gate:
the run pauses before anything reaches PyPI, shows you the tag it is about to
publish, and waits. Nothing is uploaded until someone approves, and waiting does
not consume the job's timeout.
Worth setting at the same time, under Deployment branches and tags: restrict
the environment to the tag pattern v*, so the only thing that can ever reach
PyPI is a tagged commit.
TestPyPI is a separate site with a separate account, so rehearsing needs its
own pending publisher at test.pypi.org with the environment named testpypi.
Leave that environment without reviewers — the point of a rehearsal is that it
does not need one.
Licence
MIT — see LICENSE. Declared as an SPDX expression under PEP 639 rather than a classifier, since PyPI rejects a distribution carrying both.
Status
All five kinds and every verdict in the tables above are covered, on all three platforms.
Most are produced for real: a worker is crashed, killed, signalled, wedged or
made to disagree about its collection, and the incident is read back from the
hook. Two cannot be, by anyone: OOM_KILLED needs a kernel that has just
killed something, and UNKNOWN needs a remote gateway with no local process to
query. Those branches are exercised against a constructed incident instead — as
are the Windows NTSTATUS decodes, which additionally run against a process that
really exits with one.
The opt-in paths are covered too: the memory ceiling turning an uncatchable
kill into a MemoryError that names the test, and the high-water snapshot
naming the line holding the memory.
The probes are also called directly, because in normal use they shadow each
other — psutil answers before psapi, and execnet's Popen before waitid — so
the fallbacks a customer's machine actually runs were never being executed.
That includes the claim WNOWAIT rests on: the status is read, and the process
is still reapable afterwards with the same answer.
The first cross-platform run paid for itself twice. It found that a Windows
\Lib\ in sysconfig and a \lib\ in a traceback made every stdlib frame
look like nobody's code, so a blocked test was blamed on threading.py and
then on the customer who called it — a runtime frame reported as customer code,
which is the one direction this must never fail in. Only the 3.9 cell caught
it. And it found that ctypes cannot raise an uncaught fault on Windows at all,
which is a fact about what users will see rather than about the plugin.
Download files
Download the file for your platform. If you're not sure which to choose, learn more about installing packages.
Source Distribution
Built Distribution
Filter files by name, interpreter, ABI, and platform.
If you're not sure about the file name format, learn more about wheel file names.
Copy a direct link to the current filters
File details
Details for the file pytest_failure_instrumentation-0.2.0.tar.gz.
File metadata
- Download URL: pytest_failure_instrumentation-0.2.0.tar.gz
- Upload date:
- Size: 152.5 kB
- Tags: Source
- Uploaded using Trusted Publishing? Yes
- Uploaded via:
twine/7.0.0 CPython/3.13.14
File hashes
| Algorithm | Hash digest | |
|---|---|---|
| SHA256 |
6dbbc5eda876e727a3a089b12564c3fe5a52c4ccb749b0b8a25ea20a36cb95b2
|
|
| MD5 |
17d12f35d48b75b25919f476412d52f4
|
|
| BLAKE2b-256 |
fa0fa47112aaee7f27bb2b90e9dc49f84c8e2300eb0d38c24cc7e1d65e8920a6
|
Provenance
The following attestation bundles were made for pytest_failure_instrumentation-0.2.0.tar.gz:
Publisher:
release.yml on Heknon/pytest-failure-instrumentation
-
Statement:
-
Statement type:
https://in-toto.io/Statement/v1 -
Predicate type:
https://docs.pypi.org/attestations/publish/v1 -
Subject name:
pytest_failure_instrumentation-0.2.0.tar.gz -
Subject digest:
6dbbc5eda876e727a3a089b12564c3fe5a52c4ccb749b0b8a25ea20a36cb95b2 - Sigstore transparency entry: 2588257370
- Sigstore integration time:
-
Permalink:
Heknon/pytest-failure-instrumentation@0dcd3e4170dfd60f8cca1c543b6e5c36f1918226 -
Branch / Tag:
refs/tags/v0.2.0 - Owner: https://github.com/Heknon
-
Access:
public
-
Token Issuer:
https://token.actions.githubusercontent.com -
Runner Environment:
github-hosted -
Publication workflow:
release.yml@0dcd3e4170dfd60f8cca1c543b6e5c36f1918226 -
Trigger Event:
push
-
Statement type:
File details
Details for the file pytest_failure_instrumentation-0.2.0-py3-none-any.whl.
File metadata
- Download URL: pytest_failure_instrumentation-0.2.0-py3-none-any.whl
- Upload date:
- Size: 98.9 kB
- Tags: Python 3
- Uploaded using Trusted Publishing? Yes
- Uploaded via:
twine/7.0.0 CPython/3.13.14
File hashes
| Algorithm | Hash digest | |
|---|---|---|
| SHA256 |
03107f800279894ced9641eca0aff9d4bd979db7b94b7473b20f56c9139af6bb
|
|
| MD5 |
23506625bfb932ad2c9688e56165e10f
|
|
| BLAKE2b-256 |
006ebe2c8dcaf40e9eb5834b5787bbe24e0cac8380a18aef24ea9fa3b96a8e4c
|
Provenance
The following attestation bundles were made for pytest_failure_instrumentation-0.2.0-py3-none-any.whl:
Publisher:
release.yml on Heknon/pytest-failure-instrumentation
-
Statement:
-
Statement type:
https://in-toto.io/Statement/v1 -
Predicate type:
https://docs.pypi.org/attestations/publish/v1 -
Subject name:
pytest_failure_instrumentation-0.2.0-py3-none-any.whl -
Subject digest:
03107f800279894ced9641eca0aff9d4bd979db7b94b7473b20f56c9139af6bb - Sigstore transparency entry: 2588257405
- Sigstore integration time:
-
Permalink:
Heknon/pytest-failure-instrumentation@0dcd3e4170dfd60f8cca1c543b6e5c36f1918226 -
Branch / Tag:
refs/tags/v0.2.0 - Owner: https://github.com/Heknon
-
Access:
public
-
Token Issuer:
https://token.actions.githubusercontent.com -
Runner Environment:
github-hosted -
Publication workflow:
release.yml@0dcd3e4170dfd60f8cca1c543b6e5c36f1918226 -
Trigger Event:
push
-
Statement type: